FreshAuthority vs Rookiefeed
By Jake Marsh · Reviewed · Numbers are Rookiefeed analysis as of , updated daily · How the list is built
If you want every state's new authorities, renewals and lapses for the lowest price, FreshAuthority's $49 file is the better buy. If you sell by owner name, want applicants before they have a policy, or want renewals 60 to 90 days out instead of 60, Rookiefeed does more for one state at $149. Below: the facts side by side, checked November 16, 2026.
Side by side
From FreshAuthority's homepage and pricing on November 16, 2026, and our own plans. We didn't buy a FreshAuthority plan, so the table only says what their pages say. You can see a real Rookiefeed morning email and CSV before you decide.
| FreshAuthority | Rookiefeed | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $49/month for every state ($490/year); $99/month adds a larger watchlist and change feeds | $59 one state on Mondays; $149 one state daily; $299 up to 8 states; $599 every state. Yearly = 2 months free |
| Trial | 7 days free, no card to start | 7 days of one state for $19, then the State plan unless you cancel |
| Delivery | By 6:00am Eastern, Monday through Saturday | Around 6:30 to 7:00am Central, every day there are new rows |
| New authorities | Yes, daily | Yes, daily (Weekly plan: Mondays) |
| New applicants with no policy on file | Not offered | Yes, a list you switch on |
| Insurance just lapsed | Yes, cancellations in the last 30 days with no replacement | Yes, carriers suspended after a cancellation, dropped once reinstated |
| Renewals | Policies renewing in the next 60 days, every plan | Monday renewal radar, 60 to 90 days out, on State, Regional and Nationwide |
| Owner or officer name | Not in their published 16-field list | Up to two names per row, where filed |
| Cell phone flag | Yes | Yes (31.1% of recent grants have one) |
| Insurer and effective date | Yes, the first two fields | Yes, with the coverage amount |
| First-time vs returning authority | Not in their field list | Yes |
| Application date and days to grant | Grant date only | Yes (median 24 days lately) |
| Watchlist of your own carriers | Up to 500 ($49) or 5,000 ($99) | Up to 100 (Weekly), 250 (State), 1,000 (Regional) or 5,000 (Nationwide): a morning alert when one loses or changes insurance, authority or contact details |
| Contact promise | A month free if under 95% of a file's rows have a phone or email | No promise; every row shows what is on file |
Who should buy the cheaper file
- You want every state. FreshAuthority's $49 covers the whole country; our Nationwide plan is $599.
- You want renewals and lapses at the lowest price, and 60 days of runway on a renewal is enough.
- You want the file earlier. 6:00am Eastern is 5:00am Central, an hour and a half or more before ours.
- You want to watch a large book cheaply. Their $99 plan watches 5,000 carriers; ours reaches 5,000 on Nationwide.
- You'd rather try it free with no card. Our trial costs $19.
Who should pay more for Rookiefeed
- You call by name. Rows carry up to two owner or officer names next to the phone and email.
- You write new ventures. The applicant list reaches carriers that just applied and still need a policy before FMCSA can grant them.
- You want more time on a renewal. The radar starts 90 days out, with the current insurer and the liability limit, so you can gather loss runs before the 60-day mark.
- You factor or dispatch and care about timing. Days from application to grant and the first-time flag tell a brand-new company from one coming back, and the equipment guess sorts reefers from flatbeds.
- You only need one state once a week. The Weekly plan is $59 a month for a Monday email with the same three lists.
A correction to FreshAuthority's page about us
FreshAuthority's page comparing us (checked November 16, 2026) says we have "no renewals or lapse trigger files". That isn't the case now. The lapse list has been in every plan since November 6, 2026, and the renewal radar has been part of State, Regional and Nationwide since November 12, 2026. Their page says its prices and terms were checked October 30, 2026, before either shipped. The rest of what it says about our prices, trial and free list matches our pricing.
Their page also quotes our FAQ saying contacts are as filed and some emails will bounce. That quote is accurate. The same answer reports a November 2026 check of 5,889 new carriers: 99.6% of emails were on a domain set up to receive mail, and only 4 emails and 12 phone numbers appeared on more than one carrier.
Other services people compare
Two more lists with insurance files, from their own pricing pages on November 16, 2026. Both start below our State plan, and AuthorityAlerts covers every state at its base price, so check them if price matters most.
| Service | What you get | Price and trial |
|---|---|---|
| AuthorityAlerts | Every state and thirteen lead types (new authorities, applications, insurance cancellations, renewal windows, suspensions, reinstatements, carriers at 90 days, 6 months and a year), a 2,000-carrier watchlist, a daily email with a CSV, an API once billing starts | $20/month for one person ($200/year), less per seat for teams; 7 days free, no card |
| HaulerCheck | New registrations and authorities every morning, policies renewing in 60 days with the insurer, carriers whose liability just lapsed, owner phone and email; files usually by 8am Central | $49/month one state, $99 every state, $249 with all change feeds; 7 days free, card at checkout |
| Rookiefeed | New authorities, new applicants with no policy, lapses, and the 60 to 90 day renewal radar on the daily plans; owner names, the first-time flag and days to grant on the row | $59 to $599/month by states and how often; 7 days for $19 |
Check before you buy
Pick your state on the 30-day count to see how many new carriers it had and how many have a cell phone, with no email asked. The real morning email and CSV shows every column. For more options, see the best new MC authority lead lists and how the renewal radar works. Prices change; check each vendor's page, ours included.
Questions
- Is FreshAuthority cheaper than Rookiefeed?
- Yes. On November 16, 2026 FreshAuthority's All States plan was $49 a month for every state. Rookiefeed is $59 for one state on Mondays, $149 for one state daily and $599 for every state.
- Does Rookiefeed have renewal and lapse lists?
- Yes. Every plan can include carriers whose insurance just lapsed and new applicants with no policy on file. State, Regional and Nationwide also get the renewal radar every Monday: carriers whose liability policy renews 60 to 90 days out, with the current insurer.
- Which one arrives first?
- FreshAuthority says its file lands by 6:00am Eastern, Monday through Saturday. Rookiefeed's email goes out around 6:30 to 7:00am Central, so FreshAuthority is usually earlier.
- Can I use both?
- Some agents do: a low-cost all-state file for renewals and lapses, and a daily list with owner names and applicants for the states they call every morning.
Every new carrier, by 7am
Owner name, phone, email, fleet, equipment and insurer for each carrier FMCSA authorized yesterday, as a CSV.
Related
Sources: FreshAuthority · FreshAuthority: their comparison page about Rookiefeed · AuthorityAlerts pricing · HaulerCheck pricing