GetInsureLeads alternative: every new authority, flat monthly price
By Jake Marsh · Reviewed · Numbers are Rookiefeed analysis as of , updated daily · How the list is built
Buying truck insurance prospects means choosing between paying per lead and paying a flat price for a daily list: if you want a carrier who already asked about coverage, GetInsureLeads is the better fit. GetInsureLeads sells exclusive web leads, live transfers and aged leads one at a time, while Rookiefeed sends every carrier FMCSA granted authority the day before, with the owner's contacts and the insurer on file, for one monthly price. Below: price per lead, exclusivity and timing side by side.
Side by side
From each product's public pages on October 24, 2026. We didn't buy GetInsureLeads leads, so delivery details beyond their pages aren't covered here. Where a page doesn't say something, the table says so instead of guessing.
| GetInsureLeads | Rookiefeed | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Insurance agents in nine lines, commercial truck among them | Truck insurance agents, factoring reps and dispatchers |
| What a lead is | A carrier that submitted a quote request or took a live call | Every carrier granted for-hire authority the previous day; new applications optional |
| Exclusivity | Web leads and live transfers go to one agent; aged leads are shared | Not exclusive: anyone on a plan for that state gets the same carriers |
| Contacts | Name, phone, email, business name when given, base of operations | Officer names, phone with cells flagged, email (99.7% of recent grants), street address |
| Insurance fields | Current or expiring coverage when the carrier gives it | Insurer, BIPD coverage and effective date from the FMCSA filing |
| New-authority targeting | Available as a filter, with a surcharge the page doesn't state | That's the whole list, plus first-time or returning authority and days from application to grant |
| Price | Exclusive web lead $110, live transfer $225 per call, aged from $2 to $12 | $59 to $599 a month by states covered and how often |
| Terms | Month to month, no setup or platform fees, campaign minimums on exclusive orders | Month to month; 7-day trial of the State plan for $19 |
What a month costs
The models don't compare one to one: GetInsureLeads charges for each carrier that asked about insurance, and Rookiefeed charges a flat price for every new carrier in your states, whether they're shopping or not. The table below shows what the same monthly budget buys.
| Spend per month | GetInsureLeads | Rookiefeed |
|---|---|---|
| $149 | One exclusive web lead, with change left over | Every new authority in one state, every morning (5,123 nationally in the last 30 days) |
| $299 | Two exclusive web leads, or one live transfer | Every new authority in up to 8 states |
| $599 | Five exclusive web leads, or two live transfers | Every new authority in all 50 states |
When GetInsureLeads is the better pick
- You want carriers who are shopping right now. A quote request or a live call is a warmer start than a new authority that may already be happy with the policy it filed.
- You don't want to cold call. A list of new carriers only pays off if someone dials it the same week, and exclusive leads skip most of that work.
- You want the lead to be yours alone. Our list is shared by everyone on a plan for that state.
- You write established fleets, renewals or other lines. GetInsureLeads covers carriers of any age and nine lines of insurance; we only cover new authorities.
When Rookiefeed is the better pick
- You'd rather pay one flat price than per lead. A single month of our State plan costs about what one or two exclusive leads cost.
- You want to reach new carriers before they're shopping. Most new authorities file a first policy just to get granted, and agents who call in the first weeks are in place for the first renewal or a better quote.
- You also want applicants with no insurance on file yet. Each of them needs someone to file a BMC-91 before FMCSA can grant the authority.
- You have a team that calls every morning and you'd rather fill their day with new carriers than wait on inbound volume.
Other GetInsureLeads alternatives
If you want something other than pay-per-lead, these are the other options truck insurance agents compare. Prices are from each company's public pages in October 2026. More detail: Carrier IQ alternatives and the PollyAI alternative.
| Option | What you get | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Carrier IQ | New-venture alerts, a data explorer and a built-in CRM for insurance agents | $149/month for 1 state, $199 for up to 5, $249 for up to 10 |
| PollyAI | FMCSA data with insurance expiration dates, plus a CRM | $39/month base plus $40 per state |
| TruckingSignal | A ranked call list of new authorities each morning, one agent per state | Not published |
| Shared web leads | Quote requests sold to several agents at once | About $30 to $75 per lead |
| Rookiefeed | Every new authority in your states each morning, with insurer and owner contacts | $59 to $599 a month by states covered and how often |
Using both
Many agencies buy inbound leads for closing and work a new-authority list for volume. Exclusive leads keep the closers busy with carriers who asked for a quote. The daily list gives newer producers a steady set of carriers to call, and puts the agency's name in front of each new carrier before its first renewal. See new venture trucking insurance leads for how agents work the first weeks after a grant.
For more options, see the best new MC authority lead lists in 2026 and the PollyAI alternative. Rookiefeed is $59 a month for one state once a week, $149 for one state every day, $299 for up to 8 states and $599 for every state, and you can cancel any time.
Questions
- How much do GetInsureLeads truck insurance leads cost?
- On October 24, 2026 its commercial truck page listed exclusive web leads at $110 each, interest-verified live transfers at $225 per connected call, and aged leads from $2 to $12 depending on age. New-authority and specialized-class filters carry an unstated surcharge. There are no contracts, setup fees or platform fees.
- Are Rookiefeed leads exclusive?
- No. Rookiefeed is a list of every carrier FMCSA granted authority to, so anyone on a plan for the same state gets the same carriers. That's why it costs a flat monthly price instead of a price per lead.
- Do new authorities already have insurance?
- Yes. A carrier can't be granted for-hire authority until its liability insurance (the BMC-91) is on file, so every granted carrier on the list shows its insurer and coverage. Applicants that haven't been granted yet usually have no insurance on file, and you can add them to the list.
Every new carrier, by 7am
Owner name, phone, email, fleet, equipment and insurer for each carrier FMCSA authorized yesterday, as a CSV.
Related
Sources: GetInsureLeads · GetInsureLeads: commercial truck insurance leads